Costco Customers Are Reporting Yellow Chicken—Is It Safe to Eat?

There has been growing concern about Costco’s chicken quality in recent months. From reports of greenish rotisserie chicken to rumors about packaging that may be causing illness, it’s understandable that shoppers are feeling a bit wary.

Another issue that caught my attention was that Costco customers noticed that some chicken breasts have a distinct yellow tint. Let’s dive into what’s behind this and whether it’s something to be concerned about on your next shopping trip.

Why is Costco’s Chicken Yellow?

A recent post on Reddit highlighted this issue when a user shared a photo showing Costco’s Chicken with an unusual yellow hue.

The shopper noticed that the “regular” chicken breast packs appeared noticeably yellow and contained more liquid than the organic ones.

Naturally, this raised concerns about whether the yellow indicated that the Chicken had expired or was less safe to eat. However, commenters were quick to weigh in with their knowledge, suggesting there might not be anything wrong with the Chicken at all.

What Causes Chicken to Appear Yellow?

According to the U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA), the color of raw Chicken can range from bluish-white to yellow. This color variation is mainly due to several natural factors, such as:

  • Breed: Different breeds of Chicken can have slight differences in skin tone.
  • Diet: Chickens fed on a more varied diet, which includes certain ingredients like marigold, may have yellower skin.
  • Age and Exercise: Older chickens or those that get more exercise tend to have more developed skin and fat, which can impact color.

Many consumers may need to realize that chicken skin was more yellow in past decades when a more varied diet was typical.

So, while the yellow color may look unfamiliar compared to the more standard pinkish hues we’re used to, it’s usually a result of natural factors rather than a sign of spoilage or poor quality.

Insights from Industry Insiders

Many Reddit commenters, including a former meat cutter with years of experience, agreed to reassure shoppers that Chicken’s yellow color is “pretty normal.”

This insider noted that different stores and suppliers have varying standards, so it’s common to see variations from one store to the next.

Farm-fresh chickens, for example, can be yellower due to their natural, varied diet. This difference is often masked in large-scale production, where animals may be raised under uniform diets and conditions.

What the USDA Says About Yellow Chicken

The USDA has confirmed that color alone is not a reliable indicator of freshness or safety in Chicken. Color can vary based on diet, breed, and age and may not necessarily reflect any issues with quality.

The USDA emphasizes that as long as Chicken is handled and stored correctly, it remains safe to eat regardless of slight color variations.

The USDA also notes that younger poultry may show a bluish tint because they have less fat, while older chickens can sometimes appear more yellow due to a higher fat content.

Should You Be Concerned About Yellow Chicken?

Mostly, no—yellow Chicken is generally safe to eat. If you see a yellow tint on Chicken from Costco or any other store, it doesn’t automatically mean there’s an issue with freshness or quality. To be sure, check the “sell-by” date, packaging, and how the Chicken smells. If everything else looks and smells normal, you can feel confident that cooking and eating is safe.

When buying Chicken, always prioritize proper storage and cooking to ensure safety. Chicken should be cooked to an internal temperature of 165°F (74°C) to kill any potential bacteria.

Tips for Safe Chicken Storage and Preparation

  1. Check the Sell-By Date: Always look for a valid sell-by or expiration date when buying Chicken.
  2. Smell and Appearance: Fresh Chicken should have a mild smell; a strong, sour smell can indicate spoilage.
  3. Store in the Coldest Part of Your Fridge: For optimum freshness, keep Chicken in the coldest area of your refrigerator, ideally at 40°F (4°C) or lower.
  4. Cook to the Proper Temperature: Chicken should reach an internal temperature of 165°F (74°C) to be safe for consumption.
  5. Avoid Cross-Contamination: Use separate cutting boards and utensils for raw Chicken and wash hands thoroughly after handling.

Conclusion

Seeing an unusual color on a Chicken can understandably make you pause. However, a yellow tint is typically harmless and can be attributed to various natural factors.

If you’re buying Chicken from Costco or anywhere else and come across a yellowish hue, rest assured that it’s generally safe to eat if it meets other safety standards like the sell-by date, appearance, and smell.

Next time you see yellow Chicken on the shelves, you’ll know it’s likely just a product of chickens’ diet and lifestyle. Cook it to the recommended temperature, enjoy your meal, and feel confident in your choice!

FAQs

Why does Costco’s Chicken look yellow?

Yellow Chicken can result from factors like breed, diet, and age. The USDA states that a yellow tint is natural and doesn’t necessarily indicate spoilage or poor quality.

Is yellow Chicken safe to eat?

Yellow Chicken is generally safe to eat as long as it is within its sell-by date and smells normal. The color variation is usually harmless and results from the Chicken’s diet and other natural factors.

Does a yellow color mean the Chicken is organic?

Not necessarily. While some organic chickens may have a yellower tint due to a natural diet, yellow coloring can also appear in non-organic Chickens depending on the breed and diet.

Should I avoid buying yellow Chicken?

There’s no need to prevent yellow Chicken if everything else, like the smell and sell-by date, is in order. Just make sure to store and cook it appropriately for safety.

Can yellow Chicken make me sick?

The yellow color alone will not make you sick. However, ensure that Chicken is fresh, stored correctly, and cooked to 165°F (74°C) to avoid potential health risks.

READ MORE: Thankfully, Pumpkin Pie Can Be Freezed—See How.

Leave a Comment