If you’re a fan of Jersey Mike’s, you know the thrill of ordering your hoagie “Mike’s Way,” loaded with onions, lettuce, tomatoes, red wine vinegar, olive oil blend, oregano, and a sprinkle of salt.
The iconic sub shop, known for slicing its meats fresh to order, has been a go-to for many sub lovers nationwide—including celebrities like Nick Jonas and Danny DeVito.
Most of us order the cold subs piled high with deli meats, cheese, and tasty toppings. But if you have yet to explore the hot sub-menu, you’re missing out on one of Jersey Mike’s best-kept secrets.
While the core cold sub-menu is typically consistent, Jersey Mike’s is known for rotating its hot sub-options, especially with new varieties of cheesesteaks. These limited-time hot subs bring excitement and heartbreak when favorites are taken off the menu.
Recently, Jersey Mike’s answered fans’ demands with two new hot subs that bring back an old favorite ingredient—pastrami!
Two New Pastrami Sandwiches at Jersey Mike’s
Longtime fans have been pleading for the return of Jersey Mike’s Reuben and meatball subs. While the Reuben is still in its original form, the return of pastrami on two new sandwiches, the Classic Pastrami and Chipotle Pastrami, will satisfy anyone who loves a hearty pastrami sub.
Here’s what you can expect with these two new sandwiches:
- Classic Pastrami: This sub combines layers of sliced pastrami with grilled onions, Swiss cheese, pickles, and spicy mustard for that classic deli flavor.
- Chipotle Pastrami: This sub is a twist on the classic. It includes sliced pastrami, grilled onions, Swiss cheese, and a smoky chipotle mayo.
I had the chance to try these new pastrami subs right after they launched. Here’s my honest take on each one.
My Honest Review Classic Pastrami vs. Chipotle Pastrami
While I’m typically a cold sub fan, something about a warm sandwich hits the spot. Jersey Mike’s competitor, Firehouse Subs, is famous for its hot sandwiches, but I’ve usually stuck to cold subs at Jersey Mike’s.
I went in with an open mind for this taste test, eager to see if these new additions could rival my go-to cold sub-order.
Classic Pastrami: A Perfect Balance of Flavors
I was a bit worried the Classic Pastrami would be too salty. But from the first bite, I was pleasantly surprised. The pastrami was tender, and the flavor was moderately salty. The combination of spicy mustard and pickles added just the right kick to the meat’s savory, smoky flavor.
The grilled onions and Swiss cheese melted together beautifully, creating a classic but fresh balance.
Each bite of the Classic Pastrami provided a satisfying mix of pastrami, mustard, and pickles, delivering a well-rounded flavor profile that fans of traditional pastrami sandwiches will enjoy.
Chipotle Pastrami: A Spicy, Smoky Twist
The Chipotle Pastrami offers a different experience, adding a layer of smoky, creamy chipotle mayo to the pastrami, grilled onions, and Swiss cheese. This sub has a rich, bold flavor, with the chipotle mayo enhancing the smoky notes in the pastrami.
However, I wished wish it had pickles for an added punch. The absence of pickles left me craving more contrast to the rich flavors.
Still, the Chipotle Pastrami is delicious in its own right, with an excellent cheese-to-meat ratio that adds comfort and heartiness to every bite.
What Makes Jersey Mike’s Pastrami Subs Unique?
While the two new pastrami sandwiches are undeniably tasty, they differ from the customizable subs Jersey Mike’s is known for. One of the things many fans love about Jersey Mike’s is the ability to “Mike’s Way” their sandwiches, adding and customizing toppings to suit their taste.
However, with these pastrami subs, you’re limited to the pre-set ingredients, which might be better for those who like to add more variety.
These new additions are worth trying if you still need to see Jersey Mike’s pastrami offerings. While they might not satisfy those looking for a fully loaded sub, the quality of the ingredients and the attention to flavor make these a solid choice.
Conclusion
As with any limited-time menu item, there’s no telling how long these pastrami sandwiches will stay. If you’re a pastrami fan or a longtime Jersey Mike enthusiast craving this flavor, now’s the time to try them.
While they might not be customizable, these subs offer a delicious, nostalgic flavor that’s hard to beat.
Whether you’re a fan of the Classic Pastrami’s pickled, mustardy notes or the Chipotle Pastrami’s smoky, creamy finish, each of these sandwiches offers something to enjoy. Just remember to grab one while they’re still available!
FAQs
What’s in Jersey Mike’s new Classic Pastrami sub?
The Classic Pastrami features sliced pastrami, grilled onions, Swiss cheese, pickles, and spicy mustard, creating a traditional pastrami flavor.
What’s the difference between the Classic Pastrami and Chipotle Pastrami subs?
While both subs include pastrami, grilled onions, and Swiss cheese, the Classic Pastrami has spicy mustard and pickles, while the Chipotle Pastrami has chipotle mayo for a smoky twist.
Can I customize the toppings on the new pastrami sandwiches?
The Classic Pastrami and Chipotle Pastrami come with set ingredients and don’t allow for additional toppings or “Mike’s Way” customization.
Are the new pastrami sandwiches a permanent addition to the Jersey Mike’s menu?
No, the Classic Pastrami and Chipotle Pastrami are limited-time items so that they won’t be on the menu indefinitely.
How does Jersey Mike’s pastrami compare to other sub-shops?
Jersey Mike’s pastrami is tender, flavorful, and less salty than you might find elsewhere. The grilled onions and melted Swiss cheese add a nice balance, making these hot subs a unique and tasty choice.
READ ALSO: Aldi’s $17 Roaster Is a Holiday Must-Have After Le Creuset Outsells It