Aldi has Trader Joe’s Popular Holiday Treat.

As autumn brings cozy vibes, most start reaching for pumpkin spice. However, while pumpkin fans flock to lattes and baked treats, others wait for a different seasonal flavor—peppermint’s crisp, refreshing taste.

Once Halloween is behind us and the fall decorations are packed away, the holiday season brings an irresistible peppermint takeover at grocery stores everywhere.

If you’re a peppermint lover, you know the joy of finding your favorite holiday treats on the shelves. The choices are plentiful, from Costco’s iconic peppermint bark to Häagen-Dazs’s limited-edition peppermint ice cream bars.

But one treat in particular is already creating excitement at Aldi: Benton’s Fudge Covered Peppermint Cremes.

Benton’s Fudge Covered Peppermint Cremes Are Back at Aldi—Here’s Why You Should Try Them

There’s something magical about Aldi’s exclusive holiday section, the “Aisle of Shame,” where shoppers uncover unique, budget-friendly finds.

This year, Aldi has brought back a seasonal favorite that many compare to Trader Joe’s wildly popular Dark Chocolate Covered Peppermint Joe-Joe’s.

Benton’s Fudge-Covered Peppermint Cremes, available for just $3.49, features a dark chocolate coating over an Oreo-like cookie filled with peppermint-flavored icing. Topped with crushed peppermint candies, these cookies bring a delightful crunch with every bite, capturing the essence of the holiday season.

A Fan Favorite: Why Benton’s Peppermint Cremes Sell Out Fast

Each year, fans eagerly await the return of these peppermint cookies. Benton’s Peppermint Cremes is a perfect holiday treat for any peppermint lover with their balance of dark chocolate, sweet peppermint, and satisfying crunch.

On social media, fans have shared their excitement about their return. “I love peppermint season so much more than pumpkin season!” one Reddit user posted. Another fan recommended storing them in the freezer, as the cookies become even more enjoyable with a frosty texture.

But there’s a reason these treats fly off the shelves: they’re only available for a limited time and often sell out quickly.

Aldi vs. Trader Joe’s: Which Peppermint Cookie Is Better?

How does Aldi’s version compare if you’ve tried Trader Joe’s Dark Chocolate Covered Peppermint Joe-Joe’s? Many fans find that Benton’s Fudge Covered Peppermint Cremes offers a similar taste experience but at a more budget-friendly price.

While Trader Joe’s cookies are a popular holiday item, Aldi’s version provides a comparable quality that appeals to peppermint lovers and bargain hunters.

Even though Trader Joe’s usually releases its version later in the season, Aldi has given its fans a head start. So, if you’re waiting for Trader Joe’s cookies to appear, you can get your peppermint fix at Aldi now.

And with its new green holiday packaging, Benton’s Peppermint Cremes are easy to spot among the other holiday goodies.

Tips for Enjoying Benton’s Peppermint Cremes

  1. Freeze Them – Store them in the freezer to make each bite even crisper and to add a frosty twist to the peppermint flavor.
  2. Serve with Hot Chocolate – Dunking these cookies in a warm mug of hot chocolate is a surefire way to bring holiday cheer.
  3. Use in Dessert Recipes – Crush them up to sprinkle over ice cream, or layer them in holiday desserts for an extra minty twist.
  4. Share with Friends – These cookies make an affordable and delightful addition to a holiday party or gift basket.

Why Peppermint Lovers Look Forward to the Holiday Season

For some, the holiday season begins once peppermint-flavored goodies hit the shelves. Peppermint’s incredible, refreshing taste perfectly contrasts decadent holiday treats, adding a crisp, seasonal touch to cookies, candies, and more.

While pumpkin spice brings a cozy warmth, peppermint brings a unique, wintry vibe that feels festive and nostalgic.

Peppermint fans appreciate how this flavor refreshes the palate and pairs beautifully with chocolate, making treats like Benton’s Peppermint Cremes stand out every holiday season.

Conclusion

Aldi’s seasonal aisle is a must-visit spot for budget-friendly holiday treats, and Benton’s Fudge Covered Peppermint Cremes is a standout item for peppermint lovers.

Whether you’re new to peppermint season or eagerly waiting each year for its return, these cookies are the perfect treat to kick off your holiday celebrations.

So, next time you’re at Aldi, look for the green box with festive holiday greenery. Grab a few boxes before they’re gone, and make the most of peppermint season while it lasts.

FAQs

Are Benton’s Fudge Covered Peppermint Cremes similar to Trader Joe’s Peppermint Joe-Joe’s?

Benton’s Peppermint Cremes are comparable to Trader Joe’s Peppermint Joe-Joe’s. Both have a dark chocolate coating, a peppermint-flavored filling, and a crushed peppermint topping. However, Aldi’s version is more budget-friendly.

How much do Benton’s Peppermint Cremes cost at Aldi?

Benton’s Fudge Covered Peppermint Cremes are priced at $3.49 per box, offering an affordable way to enjoy holiday peppermint treats.

Do Benton’s Peppermint Cremes have to be refrigerated?

No, these cookies don’t need to be refrigerated. However, some fans enjoy freezing them for an extra crispy texture.

Are Benton’s Peppermint Cremes available all year?

No, these peppermint cookies are seasonal items available during the holiday season. Be sure to grab them when you see them because they sell out quickly.

Can I use Benton’s Peppermint Cremes in holiday recipes?

Absolutely! Crushed peppermint cookies make a festive topping for ice cream, a crunchy layer in holiday trifles, or a fun addition to holiday dessert bars.

READ MORE: Target’s $3 Holiday-Themed Stoneware Plates are Selling Fast.

Leave a Comment